Everybody Wants to be a Historian

Noted economist Thomas Sowell fancies himself… an historian.  In his syndicated column he often pontificates on historical issues with an assumed air of expertise.  Conservatives in America accept his theories outside the realm of economics as if they were debated, peer-reviewed, and definitive.  Trouble is, outside of economics, Mr. Sowell is a novice.

Leave history to the historians…

Modern social media makes contact between scholars… easier than ever.  Practically Historical recently pointed out to Professor Sowell that his recent op-ed pieces attacking the legacy of Theodore Roosevelt were misguided and far outside the mainstream.  It was made abundantly clear that there are working historians who can inform the public about the progressive policies of Teddy Roosevelt  (and it may have been hinted which discipline is clearly superior.)

Academic squabbles are nothing new… but modern social media makes it possible for the antagonists never to square off.  Remaining true to the passive aggressive nature of economists, Professor Sowell published this column belittling the history profession and the academics who pursue it.  Good one…..I guess ? 

Try us ! We’re great at parties !

1 Comment

Filed under Ephemera, News

Best History Writers Today

If you are looking for good books… consider some choices from the best historians writing today.  Good histories are informative, scholarly, and readable.  Academics may scoff at the idea of “popular” history, but well written books stand up to any and all tests.  Here are some of the best writers working today:

5.  Joseph Ellis–Founding Brothers (Pulitzer Prize)  American SphinxFirst FamilyJoe Ellis is a professor of history at Mount Holyoke college.  His books are authoritative and readable.  For instance, Founding Brothers begins with a detailed account of the duel between Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton.

Look beyond the powdered wigs

4.  Eric Foner– The Fiery Trial (Pulitzer Prize)   Forever FreeFree Soil, Free Labor, Free MenWell respected in academia, Foner’s work has been reaching wider audiences the last decade.  His research on the Republican party has become the gold standard for all students of 19th century history.

3.  Gordon Wood– The Radicalism of the American Revolution (Pulitzer Prize)  The Idea of AmericaRevolutionary CharactersFans of the movie Good Will Hunting remember hearing Gordon Wood’s name dropped by Matt Damon.  What the film fails to convey is that Wood is the leading authority on the Founding generation.  Wood’s success stems from his scholarly and realistic portraits of our iconic founders.

Matt Damon should actually read this

2.  James McPherson–Battle Cry Freedom (Pulitzer Prize)  For Cause and Comrades This Mighty ScourgeMcPherson’s name is synonymous with Civil War history.  His research is impeccable and his volumes are always manageable.  Battle Cry Freedom is the greatest single volume history of the Civil War ever written.

1.  Nathaniel Philbrick– In the Heart of the Sea (National Book Award)  Sea of GloryMayflower.   Fans of maritime history and seafaring tales rejoice!  Philbrick spins wonderful yarns about adventure on the high seas.  In the Heart of the Sea tells the true story that inspired Melville to write Moby Dick. 

Moby Dick starts here


Filed under Uncategorized

How Have We Come so Far?

America seemed to represent the future… yet by the end of the 19th century, we became a people obsessed with our past.  A paradox not easily explained, and frankly, not wholly considered either.  The recent passing of historian Michael Kammen received little fanfare nationally, but to younger academics everywhere, it represented a melancholy turning point.


Kammen’s epic study, “Mystic Chords of Memory: The Transformation of Tradition in American Culture” was standard reading for first year grad students across academia in the mid-1990’s.  The difficult task of explaining why Americans simplify and revere their past was at the core of Kammen’s research- historians agreed with his thesis, students were primed for future frustration.  The Civil War was indeed a transformative event, radically shifting our traditions of remembrance and honor.  Prior to the war, argued Kammen, Americans viewed their past with casual indifference- the Civil War democratized our past- the masses wanted a story worthy of the sacrifices made in that most bloody struggle…American mythology began.



The good academic he was… Kammen was troubled by the wave of popular history that emerged in the 20th century.  His analysis at times bordered on whining- why don’t ordinary folks pay more attention to academic history?  To his credit, he never looked to assign blame- his study maintained an analytical approach- and his conclusions are if nothing else, valid.  But, like many writers of his background, he misses the true point of historical remembrance- pride.  Trying to explain it away with abstract concepts understood only in academic circles  is manipulative.  Our story is a complex, yet inspiring one, and the American people truly feel a part of it.  The study of history is so compartmentalized that it cannot contemplate this collective remembrance.  There is room for all types of historical study- academic, public, and popular history alike…. Kammen’s work proved it to be so… though it may not have been his intention.




Leave a comment

Filed under Book Review, News

The Art of Procrastination: Charleston, SC vs. Andrew Johnson

Originally posted on My Journey Through the Best Presidential Biographies:


Two Meeting Street Inn, Charleston, SC

I’m confident the world is anxiously awaiting a review of the third biography I’m reading on former president Andrew Johnson.

Unfortunately, a trip to the indescribably charming city of Charleston, SC interfered with my plan to finish David Stewart’s “Impeached: The Trial of President Andrew Johnson…” in a timely fashion.

A relaxing vacation to one of America’s oldest and most historic cities seems perfectly designed to inspire several hours of deep reading. After all, what could be better than a lazy afternoon spent on the wraparound porch of a magnificent Bed & Breakfast overlooking White Point Garden and the Charleston Harbor while reading a good book?


Two things interfered: the food and the historic sites. If you’ve ever been to Charleston, SC you know exactly what I’m talking about – it’s full of gastronomical, architectural and historical distractions.

Among the dozens of sites I saw…

View original 131 more words

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

I Am Impressed

Originally posted on thehistorytourist:

Heave, ho, heave, ho.  I was pulling on a rope with about 15 other people, trying to raise a sail on a British Navy schooner.  It was June 1814, and we were about to engage in the Battle of St. Leonard’s Creek.

The Battle of St. Leonard’s Creek involved a group of American barges that tried to stop the British navy from going up the Patuxent River to get to Washington DC.  It definitely was a David v. Goliath scenario.  For its 200th anniversary, there was to be a reenactment of the battle involving several tall ships.  The Pride of Baltimore II, a recreation of an 1812 schooner, was participating and taking on observers.  Excited about the opportunity not only to sail on a tall ship but to participate in a battle reenactment, I had signed on.

warof1812 180

Besides the Pride of Baltimore II, there were three other tall ships…

View original 527 more words

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Revisited Myth #21: Armless chairs were designed to accommodate women wearing wide hoop skirts.

Originally posted on History Myths Debunked:

Queen Mary I

Queen Mary I

Nonsense. Armchairs were a status indicator. According to Ron Hurst, Chief Curator and Vice-President of Collections at Colonial Williamsburg, armchairs were few in number in any given household and were intended for the head of the household or other important people. Most people of average or low status sat on backless benches or stools until the late 17th century. Female heads of state, like Queen Elizabeth I or her half-sister, Queen Mary I (pictured above), are often shown in portraits wearing huge gowns and seated in armchairs. 

Chairs without arms first appeared in the 16th century. Sometime in the 19th century, people began calling them “farthingale chairs,” linking the chair’s purpose with the wide hoops. 

This reminds me of the corner-chairs,were-for-men-with-swords myth (see #10).

View original

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Historians are not Filmmakers

Historical films cannot be 100% accurate….. filmmakers have to entertain as well as inform.  History is often complex, unsettling, even boring.  Historical movies must strike a balance between fact and fiction; finding the proper mix is often the difference between success and failure.  Critical acclaim and ticket sales are no guarantee historians will confirm a film’s accuracy.  Fickle academics will find something to criticize- none are comfortable with a Hollywood production educating the public more effectively.  Steven Spielberg’s acclaimed film, ‘Lincoln’ is already in the crosshairs of some leading historians.

Note to historians- some scenes just work.

Note to historians -some scenes just work.

Pulitzer Prize winning Lincoln scholar, Eric Fonerdisapproves of the way emancipation is depicted in the film.  Foner suggests, “Emancipation—like all far-reaching political change—resulted from events at all levels of society, including the efforts of social movements to change public sentiment and of slaves themselves to acquire freedom.”  This makes for a fine book, and Foner’s is one of the best in decades, but a major motion picture covering that much ground?  Enough scholars have praised the picture to validate the work of Spielberg and screen writer Tony Kushner.  Historians doubling as film critics have a clear problem- forget the forest, they only care to see the trees.  They also display a fundamental misunderstanding of the filmmaking process.  Professor Foner really needs to sit back, relax, and enjoy the show….rarely are historical movies this accurate…and enjoyable.


Filed under Movie Review, News