Practically Historical finally gets around to… ranking the Presidents. The criteria was laid out in an earlier post;
- Meeting the issues of the day… how well did the President address the most pertinent concerns of the electorate– not the sanitized, politically correct concerns of the scholar.
- Crisis leadership… could the President provide the necessary leadership during national crises– war is the ultimate crisis, but not the only one to be considered.
- Fulfilling the duties of the office… did the President enforce the law, defend the Constitution, supervise the military, and promote our diplomatic interests?
The Top 10 The Bottom 5 Oh so Close 5
- Lincoln 5. Grant 5. Kennedy
- Washington 4. Hayes 4. Reagan
- F. Roosevelt 3. Van Buren 3. Cleveland
- T. Roosevelt 2. Harding 2. McKinley
- Polk 1. Buchanan 1. Monroe
- Truman
- Jackson
- Jefferson
- Eisenhower
- L. Johnson

I find Polk an interesting option. Why so high on your list?
He set clear goals during the campaign, and fulfilled them all. Annexing Texas, settle the Oregon dispute, serve one term…mission accomplished. Some consider the Mexican War a drawback, but nearly doubling the size of the country is an accomplishment.
Which Cleveland, 22 or 24?