Book Review

Meacham, Jon, Thomas Jefferson; The Art of Power, Random                       House, New York, 2012.  ISBN 978-0679-64536-8

Meacham

     Pulitzer Prize winner Jon Meacham is swept away by the flood of shoddy Jefferson scholarship in his latest book, Thomas Jefferson; The Art of Power.   Meacham promises a bold new look at Jefferson’s mastery of political power, but his study falls prey to the same flimsy scholarship lesser studies are built upon.  The result fails to show what kind of study Meacham wanted this book to be.

“It was a world of desire and denial…sex between owner and property…The strange intermingling of blood and affection and silence suffused the world of the Forest that Jefferson came to know in 1770…”    Meacham explains how Jefferson learned the proper way of keeping a slave concubine from his Father-in-law John Wayles.   A strange beginning to a study of Jefferson’s poltical prowess.   But, thus is the state of Jefferson scholarship in 2013;  political correctness dictates a scholar must reconcile Jefferson the icon, with Jefferson the flawed man- in this case, sex fiend.  Meacham wastes considerable print on the sexual proclivities of our third President, when more effort was needed in the analysis of Jefferson’s troubled Virginia governorship( this period receives a scant 7 pages.)   In the same breath, Meacham gives us the idyllic Jefferson, ” loved his family; he loved Virginia; he loved his nascent nation;”  and the sexual predator “self-evidently an ardent lover…”  Jefferson’s desires kept the women close to him pregnant- vital analysis of the statesman we thought we knew.

Meacham is unsure of the book he intended to write.  A new perspective on Jefferson’s wielding of political power would have been a welcomed edition.  Unfortunately, Meacham wants it both ways; he wants to analyze Jefferson’s diplomacy in France and deduce the likelihood of a sexual encounter with Maria Cosway.  Several passages show commendable  restraint from the author, especially the misunderstood Embargo of 1807 and Jefferson’s failed attempts at abolishing slavery.  If only he had invested more energy in Jefferson’s artistic use of power, rather than pondering whether Sally Hemings resembled Martha Wayles Jefferson.   Studies such as this insure Fawn Brodie’s brand of authoritative conjecture will live on and continue to malign the good name of Thomas Jefferson.  There is a book to be found in Meacham’s efforts, sad it escaped him this time.

Advertisements

9 Comments

Filed under Book Review, News

9 responses to “Book Review

  1. NEO

    Yeah, he missed. That opening sound like the opening of a novel, and not in a good way. Geeez.

  2. Too much history is rewritten through the prism of the author’s own politics rather than the mores of the time and the facts as seen in their entirety.

  3. I think there is a place for including the personal and the inconsistencies between his principles and his behavior without having it dismissed as political correctness, but I agree that they should not be the main focus of a book that purports to be about political power. From what you say, this author seems to have lost a sense of perspective and balance.

  4. I seem not to be expressing myself clearly. I am not deducing or arguing for anything except one simple point. The simple act of exploring Jefferson’s personal life doesn’t make a work tainted by PC IF it is done with adequate scholarship and IF it is kept in an appropriate balance with the other more public aspects of his life. I even state that I AGREE, from what you say, that the book you are reviewing does not do that. So I don’t understand why you think I’m labeling him an ardent lover or deducing anything about his love life. I’m not.

    • Apologies if it seemed I accused you of anything. Exploring Jefferson’s personal life is an historical dead end by any account- exactly what he intended. Thanks again for checking in…

      • I wasn’t upset, just confused. I suspected you were still arguing the issue, not arguing with me, but I thought clarifying things would be helpful. Don’t worry. The exchange hasn’t chased me off.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s