Young and No Head

As long as young adults seek ways to… “discover themselves” and anger their parents- there will be audience for Howard Zinn’s A People’s History.   Parental units are part of the so-called establishment and our farthest reaching right-of-passage in America is fighting the conformity of the “the man.”   The biggest error in judgment these young rebels make is seeing the establishment as encompassing every facet of our existence- even our history…. Zinn is where too many young minds are exposed to distorted, often lazy examinations of these crucial moments.

howardzinnonvalencia-620x463

The failure to see our Founders as truly revolutionary… is the most damaging element in Howard Zinn’s rambling.  That’s what A People’s History is really, unsubstantiated neo-Marxist rambling.  Europeans were murdering oppressors driven by greed; Natives were peaceful environmentalists seeking harmony with nature.  The Founding of America was perpetrated by an elite few looking for a more efficient way to accrue wealth.  To Zinn and his readers this is all very provocative, but when placed under the scrutiny of peer review it is amateurish.

Maybe there's hope

Maybe there’s hope

Zinn’s work fails on many levels… but contextually he refuses to surrender bias to the complexities of human interaction.  The Pequot war was not as simple as “Red Man Good, White Man Bad.”  Our Founders were not only motivated by greed- trying explaining that to Robert Morris.  To impressionable undergrads, these arguments are their first bites from the apple of nonconformity.  To the middling academics who refuse to take Zinn to task, the book is an opportunity to gain some anti-establishment credibility with the youngsters.

 

 

 

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Book Review

2 responses to “Young and No Head

  1. We have been fed the crap taught in our public school system. How did I realize that I had been fed a bunch of crap? One day I decided I had to read the Bible. Too many things did not make sense. After I read the Bible, I did not know everything, but I knew I had to learn more about Jesus.

    Since then I have been studying the Bible. I have also been reading historic books instead of history books. You can filter out a great deal of nonsense and learn a lot about what actually happened by reading what amounts to primary source literature. With the Internet, that primary source literature is available to anyone who can afford a computer and a connection.

  2. Thank you! I returned to college at the age 52 and was astounded by the open contempt expressed toward the United States. From Charles A. Beard to Howard Zinn, revisionists are celebrated. Most of my professors were not overt subscribers to these historiographies but nearly every book we read expounded revisionist ideals.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s